Requesting an International Court of Justice (ICJ) Advisory Opinion on the 2003 Invasion of Iraq
A United Nations member state could formally initiate the process by drafting a General Assembly resolution requesting an advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on whether the 2003 invasion of Iraq violated international law.
It would not need the consent of the United States, the United Kingdom or Iraq to submit the proposal. Nor would it need approval from the United Nations Security Council.
There are two distinct parts to the process: securing adoption of a General Assembly resolution and framing a legal question that the International Court of Justice (ICJ) can properly answer.
1. The Procedure a United Nations Member State Would FollowA United Nations member state's permanent mission in New York would work with its foreign ministry and international legal advisers to draft the resolution. The text would identify the legal basis for the request, the historical circumstances and the precise question to be referred to the Court.
The proposing state could invite other United Nations member states to co-sponsor the text. Although a single state could initiate the proposal, broader sponsorship would strengthen its diplomatic prospects.
The mission would seek consideration under a suitable existing agenda item or request the inclusion of an additional item under the Assembly's rules of procedure. The precise route would depend on the session and the agenda.
The text would be submitted to the General Assembly Secretariat for circulation as an official draft resolution. Relevant procedural requirements, including those concerning programme budget implications, would need to be addressed.
The Assembly would debate the text, consider amendments and vote. The applicable majority would depend on the procedural classification of the question. There is no permanent-member veto in the General Assembly.
If adopted, the request would be formally communicated to the Court, which would then manage the advisory proceedings under its Statute and Rules.
The following is an illustrative draft, structured in the style of a United Nations General Assembly resolution. It is not an official United Nations document.
Draft Resolution
The General Assembly,
Reaffirming the purposes and principles of the Charter of the United Nations, particularly the obligation of all Member States to refrain from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any State,
Recalling Articles 2(4), 24, 39, 42 and 51 of the Charter of the United Nations,
Recalling also Security Council resolutions 678 (1990), 687 (1991) and 1441 (2002),
Noting that military operations against Iraq commenced on 20 March 2003, involving armed forces of the United States of America, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and other participating States,
Recognising the continuing importance of the international legal framework governing the use of force and the maintenance of international peace and security,
Emphasising the importance of clarifying the interpretation and application of the Charter of the United Nations concerning the use of force by Member States,
Recognising further the role of the International Court of Justice as the principal judicial organ of the United Nations,
Acting pursuant to Article 96(1) of the Charter of the United Nations and Article 65 of the Statute of the International Court of Justice,
1. Decides to request the International Court of Justice to render an advisory opinion on the following questions:
2. Requests the Secretary-General to transmit the present resolution to the International Court of Justice, together with the relevant documentation, in accordance with Article 65 of the Statute of the Court;
3. Invites Member States and relevant international organisations to cooperate with the Court in accordance with its Statute and Rules;
4. Decides to include the matter in the provisional agenda of its next session under an appropriate item concerning the rule of law at the national and international levels.
The formulation deliberately asks the Court to assess the legal position rather than asserting in advance that the invasion was unlawful.
It also separates the legality of the initial use of force from the question of legal consequences. The latter would be more complex because the Court would need to consider attribution, responsibility, the passage of time and the limits of the advisory function.
| Route | Requirements |
|---|---|
| Regular-session agenda | A member state may propose an item for the provisional agenda under Rule 13. |
| Supplementary item | Rule 14 generally requires submission at least 30 days before the session opens. |
| Additional urgent item | Rule 15 permits an important and urgent item during a regular session, subject to an Assembly decision. |
| Existing agenda item | A draft may be submitted under a suitable existing item, subject to its scope and applicable procedures. |
Rule 20 also requires an explanatory memorandum for proposed agenda items, accompanied where possible by supporting documents or a draft resolution.
For a historical question such as Iraq, the regular-session route would avoid having to justify the urgency of adding a new item during the session.
The General Assembly has 193 member states.
For a vote decided by a simple majority, only members present and voting count; abstentions are excluded.
| Voting threshold | Votes required if all 193 vote |
|---|---|
| Simple majority | 97 |
| Two-thirds majority | 129 |
Article 18 of the United Nations Charter governs voting. The two-thirds rule applies to designated important questions and any additional categories the Assembly determines. It is not an automatic requirement for every advisory-opinion request.
For example, in 2017, the Assembly adopted the Chagos advisory-opinion request by 94 votes in favour, 15 against and 65 abstentions.
A serious submission would benefit from a supporting legal memorandum addressing:
The memorandum should explain why the requested opinion would assist the General Assembly in carrying out its responsibilities, rather than merely seeking a retrospective declaration against particular states.
Article 65(2) of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) Statute requires an exact statement of the legal question and relevant supporting documentation.
The Secretary-General transmits the request, and the Court determines the subsequent procedure.
The 2017 Chagos resolution, United Nations General Assembly Resolution 71/292, is particularly useful as a drafting model.
It demonstrates that the Assembly can ask the International Court of Justice (ICJ) to examine the legality and consequences of events occurring decades earlier.
It does not guarantee that the Court would answer an Iraq request in the same way, because the underlying legal questions differ.
A United Nations member state could initiate the process by preparing a draft resolution, identifying a suitable General Assembly agenda item, securing diplomatic support and submitting the proposal through established United Nations procedures.
The absence of a Security Council veto in the advisory-opinion process is particularly significant.
However, adoption of a resolution would depend on General Assembly voting, and the International Court of Justice (ICJ) would retain discretion concerning the advisory opinion.
Recommended next step : Prepare a formal United Nations submission package consisting of :